FDA Issues Warning Over Microbial Contamination in Certain Eye Drops
Fact checked

Understanding the Legal and Health Risks: FDA’s Warning on Contaminated Eye Drops

In a recent announcement, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a stark warning against the use of certain eye drops, citing serious concerns over microbial contamination. This development raises significant legal questions, particularly regarding product safety and consumer rights.

Here are five key points to consider: 

  • The FDA has identified microbial contamination in eye drops containing methylsulfonylmethane (MSM) from Dr. Berne’s and LightEyez. 
  • MSM is a naturally occurring compound often used in alternative medicine, but these specific products are deemed unapproved and illegally marketed in the U.S. 
  • Dr. Berne’s has initiated a recall of its MSM Drops 5% Solution, while LightEyez has yet to respond to FDA’s concerns. 
  • The contaminated eye drops pose risks of minor to severe, potentially life-threatening, infections. 
  • No adverse events have been reported yet, but individuals are advised to seek medical care for any signs of eye infection. 

The legal implications of this situation are multifaceted. There is the issue of product liability. Manufacturers are responsible for ensuring the safety and efficacy of their products. In this case, the presence of microbial contamination in eye drops breaches this duty, potentially exposing the companies to legal action from affected consumers. 

The fact that these products are unapproved and illegally marketed compounds the liability. This status not only questions the regulatory compliance of the manufacturers but also highlights potential negligence in adhering to safety standards. Such actions could lead to significant penalties and stricter regulatory scrutiny. 

Consumer rights are at the forefront. Consumers have the right to safe products and full disclosure about the products they use. The lack of transparency and safety in this instance could lead to claims under consumer protection laws. 

The recall initiated by Dr. Berne’s, in contrast to LightEyez’s inaction, presents a case study in corporate responsibility and legal response to public health concerns. The differing approaches may have varying legal and reputational consequences for the companies involved. 

The absence of reported adverse events does not diminish the potential legal implications. It highlights the importance of proactive regulatory action to prevent harm and the role of agencies like the FDA in safeguarding public health. 

The FDA’s warning is not just a public health concern but a significant legal matter, emphasizing the need for stringent safety standards, corporate accountability, and consumer rights protection in the healthcare sector. 


Citation: Dillinger, Katherine. “FDA Warns Against Using Certain Eye Drops Over Microbial Contamination.” CNN, Cable News Network, 23 Aug. 2023, www.cnn.com/2023/08/23/health/fda-msm-eye-drops. 

Get a free legal case review today

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.